It is during our darkest moments that we must focus to see the light

Mwen se echantiyon yon ras kap boujonnen men ki poko donnen

Si vous voulez vous faire des ennemis essayer de changer les choses

Showing posts with label Brian Concannon. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Brian Concannon. Show all posts

Friday, March 29, 2013

28 Mars 2013: Assassinat de Mireille Durocher Bertin, Dix Huit Ans Apres par Stanley Lucas


"Ignorer les crimes, renoncer à la justice ou tolérer l'intolérable c'est renier la démocratie, c'est la réduire à un simulacre." 
Le 28 Mars 1994 Mireille Durocher Bertin etait assassine par des officiels et des sbires au service du gouvernement Haitien. Selon les informations qui circulent les ordres pour l'execution de Me. Bertin venait directement du President constitutionnel de la republique Jean Bertrand Aristide. C'etait une execution brutale. Cette avocate mere de 4 enfants en bas age fut tuee par quinze balles. Eugene Junior Ballairgeau qui etait aussi dans le vehicle crible de balles perdait aussi la vie. 

Mireille Durocher etait un avocat brillant et une militante politique tres active. Patriote, elle luttait pour le respect des lois de la republique et de la constitution d'Haiti. En 1994, Mireille Durocher Bertin publiquement plaidait pour le respect de la souverainete nationale violee par le debarquement des militaires americains et  la CIA pour reinstaller au pouvoir Jean Betrand Aristide. Bertin a demande aux instances de notre republique et particulierement au President constitutionnel de la republique Jean Bertrand Aristide de lui expliquer les references constitutionnelles qui lui ont permis de solliciter officiellement l'intervention de la CIA et des militaires des Etats Unis pour le reinstaller au pouvoir en Haiti?

Aristide savait a l'avance que les demarches de Mireille Durocher Bertin sur l'illegalite de sa demande officielle d'intervention militaire de 1994 ainsi que sa demande d'imposition d'un embargo economique sur le pays seraient condamnes par devant les tribunaux Haitiens comme des actes inconstitutionnels et illegaux.  Aristide risquait d'etre convoque par devant la Haute Cour de Justice pour être juge pour trahison et crimes contre l'humanite pour les enfants, femmes et citoyens tues par l'embargo économique. Un risque qu'il n'etait pas pret a prendre.

C'est dans ce contexte que le complot pour l'assassinat de Mireille Durocher Bertin prit naissance au palais national. Aristide voulait fermer definitivement la bouche de Mireille Durocher Bertin et bloquer toute possibilite de debat public et legal sur la question qui risquaient de provoquer le lancement d'une  procedure judiciaire contre lui, le President de la république. Le complot pour la tuer fut orchestre au Palais National. La responsabilite pour exécuter le plan fut delegue au Ministre de l'Interieur, Mondesir Beaubrun.  L'enquete du FBI publier plus tard sur l'internet révélera que le ministre de l'interieur Beaubrun, le coordonnateur de l'assassinat de madame Bertin, suivait a la lettre les instructions données par Jean Bertrand Aristide. L'execution de Bertin provoqua un scandale et une revolte.

Suite a l'enquête du FBI, a cause de l'implication directe dans l'assassinat de Bertin, le Ministre Mondesir Beaubrun fut mis de cote pour la visite officielle du President Clinton sur demande de l'administration americaine. L'enquete sur l'assassinat identifia les freres Eddy et Patrick Moise comme les tueurs employés par le ministere de l'Interieur pour exécuter Mireille Durocher Bertin. Les armes utilisees par les freres Moise ont ete enregistrées et fournies par le ministère de l'Intérieur ainsi qu'un véhicule tout Izuzu Trooper de couleur grise. Les freres Moise avaient aussi en leur possession des cartes d'identification du Ministere de l"Interieur. Pour plus de details sur l'enquete du FBI klike la: http://www.haitiwebs.com/showthread.php?t=51970 Cette decouverte des enqueteurs sur l'implication des freres Moise dans l'assassinat de Bertin suscita des inquietudes au palais. Il fut decide au Palais National d'executer immediatement les deux freres Moise pour eviter qu'ils parlent devant un tribunal.

L'execution des freres Moise aura lieu a Leoagne. Ils furent assassines dans leur sommeil a 5:00 am par le regime alors qu'ils etaient dans leur sommeil, selon les témoignages de policiers de la Swatt team. Le trio tout puissant qui controlait la police a l'epoque coordonnait l'execution. Les instructions donnees pour cette operation de la SWATT team, ne ramenez pas les freres Moise vivants! 

Le ministre de la justice en poste Jean Joseph Exume qui etait l'un des conseillers privilegies d'Aristide en sait long sur cette affaire. Aucune question d'aucune institution, ni de la presse. Il n'a jamais rien dit et il fait toujours semblant. Il veut oublier ou peut etre a-t-il peur de parler pour ne pas connaitre le sort de Venel Joseph?

Dix huit ans apres aucune enquête, aucune condamnation, qucune question, aucune réponse et aucune procédure judiciaire. La grande question, pourquoi, restee sur les lèvres est relancee par Anne-Rose Schoen:. Cette année je reprendrai les onze questions d'Anne-Rose Schoen:
  1. En effet, Maitre Mireille Durocher Bertin, personnage public, était encouragée dans ces prises de position par plusieurs secteurs de la société haïtienne. Cependant ces mêmes entités n’ont pas jugées bon de condamner sa mort. Je me demande : POURQUOI ?
  2. Maitre Mireille Durocher Bertin, femme, épouse et mère de 4 enfants, n’a pas non plus bénéficiée de la condamnation de son assassinat par les multiples associations féminines, qui militent sur le terrain et dont elle a été la fondatrice d’au moins une. Ces organisations des femmes vaillantes, ces « poto mitan » de la société sont restées muettes jusqu’à aujourd’hui? Je me demande : POURQUOI ?
  3. Maitre Mireille Durocher Bertin, de son vivant, travaillait souvent gratuitement pour les associations de marchandes, leur expliquant leurs droits et devoirs et défendant certaines gratuitement au Parquet de Port-au-Prince. Pourtant, aucune association ou fédération du secteur informel n’a élevé la voix pour condamner ce crime crapuleux. Je me demande : POURQUOI ?
  4. Maitre Mireille Durocher Bertin défendait passionnément les droits de l’enfant, s’opposant contre le fléau du système restavec, contre les abus dans les procédures anarchiques d’adoption en Haïti et contre le trafic de ce que nous appelons aujourd’hui communément l’Esclavage Moderne. Bizarrement, aucune association de droit de l’homme, de la femme ou de l’enfant n’a jugé bon, même 18 années après, de condamner ce qui est arrivé. Je me demande : POURQUOI ?
  5. Maitre Mireille Durocher Bertin, avocat, membre du Barreau de l`Ordre des Avocats de Port-au-Prince, a été assassinée avec son client en plein exercice de ses fonctions, jusqu'à date, le Barreau est resté silencieux…Je me demande : POURQUOI ?
  6. La société civile, ainsi que ses associations qui œuvrent pour l’installation de la démocratie, pour un progrès socio-économique et pour un état de droit pour tous et toutes en Haïti, n’a pas non plus montré son désaccord par rapport à cette disparition subite et terrible d’une force vive et engagée de son propre milieu. Je me demande : POURQUOI ?
  7. Les associations patronales, qui comptaient et qui comptent toujours parmi elles beaucoup de clients de Maitre Durocher Bertin, ont préféré de mettre leurs têtes dans le sable ou imiter la fameuse sculpture des trois singes qui ne voient rien … n’entendent rien… ne disent rien…Je me demande : POURQUOI?
  8. Une organisation internationale de défense des droits de l’homme me déclarait par la suite et durant une conversation téléphonique en décembre 1995, qu’elle ne comptait pas défendre le cas d’un des amis de Mireille incarcéré illégalement, car il avait et je cite « politiquement la mauvaise couleur » et qu’elle ne pouvait pas se permettre en 1995 de défendre le cas d’un mulâtre en Haïti…Je me demande : POURQUOI ?
  9. Partout ou le nom de Maitre Mireille Durocher Bertin surgit, les intervenants utilisent l’exemple à leurs propres fins ou tournent tout simplement le dos, en déclarant qu’elle aurait dû s’arrêter … se taire, quand elle en avait encore le temps. Je me demande : POURQUOI ?
  10. Personne ne s’est mis à manifester au grand jour en criant « plus jamais » - comme cela a été le cas pour tant d’autres victimes d’un crime violent.Je me demande : POURQUOI ?
  11. Nous sommes restés muets et nous restons toujours muets, prétendant que cet assassinat n’a jamais eu lieu ou qu’il fait partie de la chronique des faits divers. Je me demande : POURQUOI ?

Anne-Rose Schoen ajoutes: "Ce sont là mes réflexions personnelles sur une situation qui perdurent depuis trop longtemps … 18 longues années, et qui devrait, à mon sens, révolter la conscience de plus d’un. Quelle organisation, institution, association, fédération privée ou publique condamnera finalement l’assassinat de cet être humain, commis il y a 18 années déjà ? Lui rendant ce minimum de respect dont toute personne devrait bénéficier de nos jours ? Tous les crimes se doivent d’être condamnés, y compris celui de Mireille et celui-ci ne l’a toujours pas été… Je me demande : POURQUOI ? Quelqu’un pourra-t-il un jour me répondre … ? POURQUOI ?"
Mireille Durocher Bertin, Brignol Lindor, Pasteur Antoine Leroy, Jacques Fleurival, Jacques Roche, Senateur Yvon Toussaint, Michel Gonzalez, le General Mayard, Jean Dominique, le Pere ti Jean et tant d'autres mentionnes dans la lettre du Senateur Irvelt Chery, klike la: http://www.haitian-truth.org/liste-partielle-des-victimes-et-magouilles-du-lavalas/ font partie d'une longue liste de citoyens executes par lavalas pour des raisons politiques. Leurs familles souhaitent des actions de la  justice mais elles ne font rien parce qu'elles sont menacees et ces familles ont peur. Les bourreaux sont toujours puissants, ils continuent de defier les autorites judiciaires, de marcher et de cracher sur les victimes. Recemment constatez avec quelle facilite ces bourreaux ont tue devant sa residence l'ancien gouverneur de la Baque Centrale Venel Joseph qui voulait temoigner devant un tribunal des Etats Unis sur la corruption de l'epoque dans l'administration publique d'Haiti! 

Que faire? Pour qu'il y ait justice nous devons conforter et sécuriser les familles victimes et les témoins. Nous devons travailler a la reforme de la justice pour que l'egalite des citoyens devant la loi devienne une realite. Nous devons nous battre pour traduire les bourreaux, sans abus, devant la justice. Mireille Durocher Bertin que la terre te soit legere!

Saturday, February 23, 2013

JUGEMENT DUVALIER, PREVAL, ARISTIDE ET NATIONS UNIES: COMMENT ETABLIR LE REGIME DE LA LOI EN HAITI? PAR STANLEY LUCAS


    Click image to enlarge

La democratie etablit un regime de la loi ou les citoyens sont egaux devant les lois etablies d'un pays. Dans une democratie les dossiers judiciaires ne peuvent pas etre traites en fonction des contacts ideologiques ou politiques ou de la force de lobby des accuses. L'administration de la justice sans comparaison des cas doit traiter l'ensemble des citoyens de la meme facon sans parti prix. 

En Haiti le gouvernement du President Michel Martelly depuis son arrivee au timon des affaires de l'etat le 14 Mai 2011 travaille a l'etablissement d'un etat de droit. Ce qui a ete refuse aux citoyens d'Haiti depuis la ratification par le peuple et la publication de la constitution du 29 Mars 1987. Pour la premiere fois depuis vingt cinq ans l'equipe Martelly avec la contribution du parlement a installe dans ses fonctions le Conseil Superieur du Pouvoir Judiciaire (CSPJ). C'est un exemple concret des efforts en cours pour reformer la justice haitienne pour la rendre professionnelle et equitable. Mais ces efforts risquent de n'aller nul part si les lobbyistes etrangers en fonction de leur passe corrompus avec certains leaders d'Haiti continuent de solliciter une justice partisane. Depuis leur retour en Haiti les anciens Presidents Jean Claude Duvalier et Jean Betrand Aristide posent un grand defi pour le systeme judiciaire haitien voir: http://solutionshaiti.blogspot.com/2011/01/duvalier-returns-to-haiti-merely-pawn.html 

C'est un sujet difficile et dangeureux mais il faut l'aborder car il s'agit de l'avenir d'Haiti. Certains diront que je suis fou de poser le probleme. Haiti doit trouver des solutions institutionnelles a ses problemes. Ce n'est pas la MINUSTAH et Amnesty International avec leurs prefeences ideologiques qui aideront Haiti a etablir l'etat de droit. Leur double standard dans le traitement des dossiers judiciaires d'Haiti est une preuve incontestable. Comment voulez-vous que les Nations Unies qui ont contamine Haiti avec le cholera et cause 7000 morts et 800.000 contamines peuvent-ils parler de justice alors qu'ils refusent de reconnaitre leur cupabilite dans la propagation de l'epidemie pretextant l'immunite? Comment des lobbyistes comme Brian Concannon et ses allies peuvent parler de justice alors que ce dernier s'est enrichi et est devenu millionaire sur le dos du peuple haitien grace a la corruption bienveillante de l'ancien dicateur Jean Betrand Aristide? Quand est-ce que les 7000 morts du cholera des Nations Unies en Haiti trouveront justice? Qui remboursera Haiti les US$2.5 milliards de dollars americains necessaires que ca coutera pour nettoyer le pays du cholera des Nations Unies? Est-ce que le Dr. Paul Farmer assistant du Secretaire General des Nations Unies peut etre a la fois juge et partie sur ce dossier? Comment en toute conscience l'expert des Nations Unies en droits humains Michel Forst peut-il parler de justice et de droits humains en Haiti quand il refuse de reconnaitre l'injustice fait aux haitiens par la mission des Nations Unies en Haiti, MINUSTAH, responsable de la propagation de la bacterie cholera qui a tue 7000 de nos freres? Est-ce que les Nations Unies ne devraient apprendre des lecons de leurs experiences negatives dans le genocide du Rwanda?
        Click image to enlarge

C'est a nous haitiens de construire nos institutions. La justice influencee par des interets etrangers particuliers est dangeureuse pour Haiti. Nous ne pouvons pas continuer dans cette spirale de defense des interets indefendables de moun panou. Il faudra finalement etablir des regles de justice que tout le monde devra respecter, riches ou pauvres, chefs ou gouvernes. Cela passe par l'etablissement du regime de la loi ou de l'egalite des citoyens devant la loi. La justice ne peut pas etre et ne doit pas etre un outil ideologique ou un istrument politique partisan comme le voudrait certaines organisations internationales liees a Aristide et a Duvalier. La justice ne peut pas etre non plus un istrument de vengeance. Vengeance de ceux qui ont ete des victimes des regimes qui se sont succedes. Ce sera penible mais il faudra travailler a l'etablissement de l'etat de droit pour donner une chance a Haiti, ses enfants et sa democratie.  Depuis les debarquement a l'aeoport de l'ancien president a vie Jean Claude Duvalier et de l'ancien president Jean Betrand Aristide le debat sur le jugement de ces anciens presidents fait rage. Leurs lobbyistes Haitiens et etrangers iterferent, sabotent le processus judiciaire a travers des technicalites et font de leur mieux avec leurs influences pour bloquer le travail des juges de la republique. C'est carrement inacceptable!

Jean Claude Duvalier est accuse d'avoir commis des crimes contre des citoyens de la republique qui ont ete executes durant son regime, voir: http://www.fordi9.com/Pages/Victlist/ListA.htm Duvalier est aussi accuse d'avoir detourne plus de US$600 millions en 14 ans selon le rapport officiel de l'etat haitien ecrit par l'ancien Ministre des Finances Leslie Delatour voir: http://www.scribd.com/doc/47415168/BRH-CORRUPTION-Dossiers-Jean-Claude-Duvalier-15-janvier-1987 

Jean Betrand Aristide est accuse d'avoir commis des crimes contre de nombreux citoyens haitiens. Deux listes de citoyens executes par le regime de Jean Betrand Aristide sont disponibles. La premiere a travers une lettre du senateur Irvelt Chery qui demande aux commissaires du gouvernement de prendre les mesures necessaires pour que les victimes trouvent justice, voir: http://www.haitian-truth.org/liste-partielle-des-victimes-et-magouilles-du-lavalas/ et une autre liste plus large icluant l'ensemble des regimes lavalas: http://www.haitian-truth.org/les-assassinats-en-haiti-sous-le-regime-de-lavalas-et-de-preval/ Jean Betrand Aristide selon les rapports officiels de l'etat d'Haiti est aussi accuse d'avoir detourne plus de US$350 millions en neuf ans voir: http://www.haitipolicy.org/content/3284.htm En plus, Aristide a travers le pillage du reseau des telecommunications en Haiti a enrichi des personnalites americaines avec des connections politiques. De la compagnie de telecommunication FUSION en 1994-95 jusqu'a IDT Aristide a toujours menace ces americains de reveler ce qu'il sait s'il n'etait pas proteger. Ce chantage dure plus de quinze ans. Aristide a declare en Haiti que le succes des elections de 2015 aux Etats Unis dependait de la protection qu'il recevrait pour ne pas paraitre devant la justice haitienne ou americaine. Le dossier IDT est deja devant la justice americaine dans l'etat de la Floride. Deux journalistes des Etats Unis Mary'O'Grady du Wall Street Journal et Lucy Komisar une liberale http://www.thekomisarscoop.com/tag/haiti/ ont ecrit en details sur ce dossier de corruption. Selon les fonctionnaires haitiens ces personnalites etrangeres menacees par Aristide font de leur mieux pour faire disparaitre les dossiers les impliquant, particulierement a la Banque Nationale de la republique d'Haiti (BRH). C'est pour cette raison que l'ancien gouverneur de la BRH Venel Joseph a ete execute recemment parce qu'il allait temoigner devant un tribunal de la Floride sur ce dossier de corruption. Est-ce que ces forces font pression sur la justice haitienne pour empecher le jugement d'Aristide?

Bien qu'il n'existe pas de rapports officiels sur sa corruption le president sortant du 14 Mai 2011, Rene Preval pourrait aussi faire face a des poursuites judicaires, pour la corruption des fonds du petrocaribe, nous utilisons ce lien: http://www.haitian-truth.org/lodeur-des-dollars-de-petrocaribe/ puisque le Nouvelliste a efface sur son site l'article original genant pour l'ancien president Rene Preval http://www.lenouvelliste.com/article.php?PubID=&ArticleID=83102 L'ancien President Preval risque aussi d'etre questionne sur l'assassinat de Robert Marcelo, cliquez ici: http://www.haitian-truth.org/ou-est-passe-joseph-robert-francois-marcello-par-pierre-raymond-dumas/ puisque le nouvelliste a aussi fait disparaitre l'article suivant: http://www.lenouvelliste.com/articleforprint.php?PubID=1&ArticleID=82527  Les analystes sont d'accord qu'il sera difficile de questionner l'ancien President Preval sur les citoyens tues et brules a Lalue et sur la route de Bourdon le 7 janvier 1991 sous pretexte qu'ils etaient des macoutes

Selon le teledjol haitien Duvalier et Aristide utilisent leurs lobbyistes en Haiti et aux Etats Unis pour echapper a la justice d'Haiti. Ils essaient de beneficier de supports a l'etranger pour saboter les procedures judiciaires d'Haiti. Duvalier paie l'ancien Congressman Bob Barr, voir: http://stage.newser.com/story/110436/ex-gop-rep-helping-baby-doc-get-his-cash.html Tandis que les supporters de Jean Betrand Aristide sont le Dr. Paul Farmer et son associe Brian Concannon sont ceux identifies par des secteurs de la population haitienne et de la diaspora. Ces deux utilisent leurs positions aux Nations Unies et au sein de leur mission en Haiti, la MINUSTAH, leurs contacts politiques aux Etats Unis pour saboter les efforts de la justice Haitienne pour juger Jean Betrand Aristide. Brian Concannon a travaille longtemps avec Paul Farmer, Concannon a ete pendant longtemps un lobbyiste de l'ancien President Jean Betrand Aristide qui l'a rendu millionnaire. voir: http://www.haitipolicy.org/Lobbying7.htm  Aristide compte aussi sur le support du lavalassien Robert (Bob) Maguire qui travaille au Peace Institute et son reseau d'ideologues, pour plus de details voir: http://solutionshaiti.blogspot.com/2011/03/truth-about-aristide-mob-boss-or.html Tandis que Rene Preval fait confiance aux hommes d'affaires haitiens qu'il a faciliter l'enrichissement durant sa presidence. 

Selon les victimes et les rapports officiels disponibles de l'etat d'Haiti ces anciens presidents Duvalier et Aristide ont causes de grands torts au pays. Je n'ai ni fabrique les victimes, ni les rapports administratifs du gouvernement Haitien sur la corruption de ces anciens presidents. Cette conversation doit etre franche. En tant que peuple nous devons garder notre calme, sans passion, avec sang froid determiner comment allons nous aborder les accusations sur les violations de droits humains et les de detournements de trois anciens presidents de la republique: Jean Claude Duvalier (1971-86). Jean Bertrand Aristide (1991-95 - 2001-04), Rene Preval (1996-2000 - 2006-11). Comment allons-nous garantir que chacun d'eux recoive un traitement equitable devant la justice tout en envoyant un message clair aux futurs presidents d'Haiti? Quel modele suivre? Celui du Perou avec la mise en accusation et l'emprisonnement de l'ancien President Alberto Fujimori? Celui des Phillippines avec le president Joseph Estrada? Du Venezuela avec Andres Perez? De la France ou le juge d'instruction a entame une procedure contre les anciens Presidents Jacques Chirac et Nicolas Sarkozy? Ou celui de la republique Dominicaine avec Joaquim Balaguer? Faudra-t-il supporter la justice? Devra-t-on discuter au nom de la reconciliation de l'autorite constitutionnelle du President de la republique de donner ou ne pas donner l'amnistie?

En abordant le dossier judiciaire de ces anciens presidents de la republique d'Haiti nous ne devons pas oublier la partie invisible de l'iceberg dont la presence aux abords du pouvoir de la presidence a ete permanente autour de ces trois decennies. Je veux dire il ne faut pas oublier les hommes du groupe de bourdon dans l'ombre qui ont tire les avantages et "assister" les trois presidents dans leur corruption. Le groupe de bourdon est un cartel economique haitien forme de 17 hommes qui controlent 90% des activites economiques d'Haiti et une grande partie des medias. Ils sont les gagnants permanents du systeme et la partie de l'iceberg que la justice n'arrive jamais a toucher. On parle de tout le monde sauf d'eux. Le groupe de bourdon est le gardien de ce systeme feodal qui maintient Haiti dans la pauvrete et le sous developpement politique. Courir seulement apres Duvalier, Aristide, Preval et les corrompus de Lavalas, Lespwa, INITE ect... sans poser la problematique et le role du groupe de bourdon dans le soutien de ces politiques feodales se lave main siye ate. Ces seigneurs feodaux du groupe de bourdon ne peuvent pas etre non plus au dessus de la loi. 

Tout accuse est innocent jusqu'a ce qu'il soit reconnu coupable. La justice Haitienne doit faire son travail et c'est la seule facon que notre pays peut commencer a construire un etat democratique. Je suis sur que chacun de ces anciens presidents maintient une base prete a crier Duvalier ou la mort, Preval ou la mort, Aristide ou la mort accompagnes des relais de leurs lobbyistes etrangers bien payes. Mais cela ne doit pas nous faire peur. Cela fait  partie du combat pour l'etablissement du regime de la loi, du combat contre les corrompus et les jusqu'auxboutistes qui empechent la democratie haitienne de fleurir et nos institutions de repondre aux besoins de notre peuple en lieu et place d'un petit groupe. Dans ce combat nous devons aussi faire attention aux organisations de droits humains qui veulent une justice sur une base ideologique, cette formule risque de garantir l'instabilite politique pour Haiti. 

La philosophie de gestion du pouvoir par le groupe de bourdon est simple et sans etat d'ame par rapport au pays et ses citoyens: le roi est mort vive le roi! Comme les musiciens de palais une fois le chef-President dechouke ou remplace par des elections ils s'empressent toujours de faciliter l'entree d'un nouveau chef qui defendra leurs interets. Depuis le 14 Mai 2011 ils sont a l'assaut du President Martelly qui jusqu'a present resiste a leur charme mortel. Nous devons nous battre democratiquement pour empecher et bloquer ce jeu macabre du groupe de bourdon dont la repetition au cours des decennies fait des victimes et detruit Haiti. Luttons pour garantir que cette pratique ne soit plus un eternel recommencement. La question centrale pouvons-nous detruire ce systeme feodal qui ensevelit notre pays au niveau economique, social et politique? Pouvons-nous trouver le leadership judiciaire ayant le courage d'affronter ce systeme? C'est ca le pari a gagner pour une Haiti democratique.

Wednesday, November 16, 2011

Cholera in Haiti: New Opportunity for Funding Foreign NGOs by Stanley Lucas


    Brian Concannon
The Institute for Justice & Democracy in Haiti (IJDH) and their Haitian affiliate the Bureau des Avocats Internationaux (BAI) filed complaints with the United Nations on behalf of 5,000 Haitian cholera victims.  In October 201, a severe cholera epidemic broke out in Haiti killing 7,000 people and sickening another half million.  While the UN denied having any involvement in the introduction of the epidemic, Haiti had not seen a case of cholera in more than 50 years and the strain was traced back to South Asia where some of the UN troops resided (see: 1. http://solutionshaiti.blogspot.com/2010/11/cholera-in-haiti-is-united-nations.html 2. http://www.cdc.gov/media/pressrel/2010/r101101.html  )

Now the IJDH and BAI are raising money to pursue the case.  They are requesting a minimum of USD 100,000 to compensate each victim who died from cholera, plus reasonable attorney’s fees and legal costs and expenses; and a minimum of USD 50,000 to compensate each victim who suffered illness and injury from cholera, plus reasonable attorney’s fees and legal costs and expenses. 

Furthermore, without ever approaching the Haitian Government, they have taken it upon themselves to also request, “that the UN enter into an agreement with
the Government of Haiti to establish and fund a countrywide program for clean water, adequate sanitation and appropriate medical treatment, to prevent the further spread of cholera.   The funds in this settlement should be furnished by the UN and allocated for measures that will end the cholera epidemic, including measures that improve (i) water quality and access; (ii) sanitation conditions; and (iii) access to medical services.”  They also note that, “Such measures will also limit the long-term liability of the UN for claims associated with cholera.”

At best, this seems an attempt to secure compensation for victims.  However, at worst, it seems an opportunistic attempt to capitalize on a tragic situation for fund raising purposes.  It is also unclear if the IJDH and BAI will collect a portion of the settlement, as is standard practice for tort lawyers or civil cases.  If so, there is an awful lot of money at stake.

The reason I am raising these questions is due to the head of IJDH’s track record in Haiti.  Mr. Brian Concannon has a long association with former Haitian President Aristide, who retainer Mr. Concannon for US$50.000/month paid for out of the meager coffers of the Haitian Government ( see: http://www.haitipolicy.org/Lobbying7.htm ).  His interests have seemed more to align with turning Haiti’s challenges and weak position into economic opportunity for him and his non-profit. 

Further, what is equally concerning is Mr. Concannon’s approach to this challenge.  Rather than offer the Haitian Government the technical and legal support to file and organize this case, he circumvented the government and pursued this project on his own.  This has been exactly the approach that has resulted in the failure of foreign aid in Haiti.  Many NGOs prefer to avoid the Haitian Government because it is weak and corrupt.  However, avoiding the Government only reinforces Haiti’s challenges.  Working to build capacity in the Government and train young Haitian prosecutors on how to file such a case would have actually left a lasting legacy of capacity with the Haitian system, which in turn would have strengthened the Government and its ability to provide for its people.  But that approach is very hard, and may not result in a big financial settlement.  It is much easier to exploit opportunities for your own organization’s gain.  In the end, I just hope that the 5,000 people that they promised justice, will actually see justice and receive some of that compensation

Thursday, March 17, 2011

The Truth About Aristide: Mob Boss or Persecuted Priest? by Stanley Lucas


Over the past 50 years, Haiti has suffered under the rule of strongmen:  Francois “Papa Doc” Duvalier followed by his son Jean Claude “Baby Doc” Duvalier, Jean Bertrand Aristide, and, most recently, Rene Preval.  This procession of corrupt, self-serving and violent leaders has left Haiti, a country with a proud history of being the first black republic in history, as one of the world’s tragedies – a true failed state.  Haiti is the poorest country in the Western Hemisphere, one of the most corrupt countries in the world, and ranks at the bottom for every health and social metric.  After the January 12 earthquake and a devastating cholera epidemic, Haiti is literally in shambles.

Time and time again, the Haitian people have stood up against these leaders sending them into exile.  Now Haiti’s most infamous strongmen are vying for a role in their country once again.  Duvalier has returned to “help out”, see: http://solutionshaiti.blogspot.com/2011/01/duvalier-returns-to-haiti-merely-pawn.html ; Aristide is whipping up his supporters in-country and his international network to demand his return; and Preval is just stubbornly clinging to power by robbing the Haitian people of free and fair elections.  The international community – tested by other priorities and hot spots around the world – has paid little attention to Haiti.  The US government issued statements about Haiti needing to “look forward” rather than “looking back” to the old days under these leaders.  President Obama has called President Zuma of South Africa to express concern about Aristide’s return to Haiti from exile in South Africa.  The U.S. State Department issued a statement saying that the timing of Aristide’s return "can only be seen as a conscious choice to impact Haiti's elections." 

Aristide says he is going back because he is afraid that a newly elected President would revoke his passport.

Aristide was the buddy of the Clinton Administration when he requested military intervention from the United States to reinstate him to power in 1994, see: http://www.c-spanvideo.org/program/60373-1  For those who know Aristide -- the Haitian people, the Haitian Diaspora and some actors in the international community -- they have learned over the years that Aristide never keep his word. Before returning to Haiti in 1994 he promised the Haitian people and the Clinton Administration that he would organize free and fair elections, respect human rights, professionalize the police and the army, create jobs, invest in education and ensure good governance.  After his return, he did just the opposite.  His campaign of violence started right before the visit of President Clinton to Haiti in March 1995 with the execution of Me. Mireille Durocher Bertin.  The FBI linked the murder to then Minister of Interior Beaubrun who executed Aristide’s order and contracted the murder.  Aristide politicized the police, rigged elections, stole state resources and systematically violated the rights of women, peasants, youth, press, and religious groups.  No one was safe.  The Haitian people never tolerate such ruthless corruption.  In 2004 on the eve of the celebration of Haiti's 200 years of independence, they rose up against him and called for his resignation. In an effort to stop and repress the Haitian democratic activists around the country, Aristide requested from South African President M'Beki a military force to violently crackdown on the Haitian protests, see: http://metropolehaiti.com/metropole/archive.php?action=full&keyword=mbeki+aux+gonaives&sid=0&critere=0&id=7742&p=1 .  As a reminder of those who stood up against the dictator see the following links:

·          Grassroots organizations: http://www.potomitan.info/ayiti/ayiti6.html
·         Antineoliberal Groups: http://www.alterpresse.org/spip.php?article1091

       After the popular revolt, Aristide was rescued by the United States and was transported to South Africa – one of the only countries willing to take him.  Prior to his departure, he submitted his resignation.  After the dust had settled, he began a media campaign alleging that he was kidnapped by the United States and was forced into exile.  His own Prime Minister, Yvon Neptune, refutes that claim and has publicly stated that his claim of kidnapping were bogus, and he personally accepted Aristide’s resignation, see: http://radiokiskeya.com/spip.php?article7105

Both candidates have said that Aristide is welcome to return.  Haiti observers speculate that he is returning in order to disrupt and undermine the elections to create chaos in-country and prevent a newly elected government from auditing and exposing all the corruption and collusion with foreign profiteers that took place under Aristide’s reign.


The UN recently announced they would work with the Haitian Government to support their efforts to try Duvalier for his crimes.  Given Aristide’s public efforts to return, Haitians were surprised that they singled out Duvalier rather than offering to put together a framework to try any corrupt officials.  Haitians wondered whether the high profile support for Aristide by senior UN officials, namely Deputy UN Special Envoy Paul Farmer, was going to translate into a partisan approach to addressing corruption and human rights abuses in Haiti, see: http://solutionshaiti.blogspot.com/2011/02/united-nations-partisanship-in-haiti-by.html

    Click on picture to enlarge

Aristide has almost completely evaded international scrutiny for the atrocities and corruption he committed while in office.  He has been wrapped in a powerful cocoon of international support that he has managed to cobble together.  His network includes idealists who view Aristide as a humble priest fighting against American imperialism and racial subjugation and foreign “profiteers” who have made money with Aristide through corrupt business dealings or lucrative lobbying retainers.  This alliance has risen to Aristide’s defense time and time again painting him as a champion of the poor, and a persecuted victim of the imperialist United States and western powers.  By extension, they paint his political party and support base in Haiti, Fanmi Lavalas, as Haiti’s most popular political party that has been unfairly excluded from participating in the electoral process.  Their efforts have resulted in scant press coverage detailing Aristide’s crimes, and extensive coverage outlining his unfair persecution.  They eschew the facts and evidence against Aristide in favor of invective, vicious accusations and conspiracy theories.  Anyone who critiques Aristide ends up the subject of personal attacks and baseless character assassination campaigns.  These foreign operators in particular single out Haitians in the Diaspora and in-country fighting for a better and more democratic future for their own country.

All evidence during Aristide’s, however, inconveniently points to the contrary.  Aristide has a well-documented track record as being a brutal power monger willing to leverage any ideology -- and Haitian resources -- to maintain his grip on power to enrich himself and his allies.  The economic and political crimes he committed while in office have set Haiti’s growth back decades.  His “popular” Lavalas party is anything but popular with the Haitian people.  The Party had an abysmal showing in the 2006 legislative elections (the last elections they participated in) winning only six of the 99 Deputy seats and three of the 30 Senate seats up for election.  Led by Aristide, Lavalas operates like a crime syndicate or a mob family trafficking in drugs, taking out political hits, and pilfering state resources.  Lavalas is Tonton Macoutes 2.0. 

Aristide’s Lavalas Crime Syndicate
The Lavalas Party finances its political activity largely through criminal activity including kidnapping and drug trafficking.  Almost all increases in Lavalas political or electoral campaign activity is linked directly with a surge in criminal acts and violence in Haiti.  More than 99% of all corruption cases, kidnapping cases and drug trafficking arrests involve people with links to Lavalas.  The following is a summary of the nettlesome facts about Aristide and Lavalas operations.


Drug Trafficking
Lavalas has long used drug trafficking to finance its political activity and electoral campaigns.  Almost 99% of the arrests by Haiti’s National Police and the U.S. Drug Enforcement Agency (DEA) for drug trafficking are linked to Lavalas and Aristide.  The most famous case was against “Jacques” Beaudouin Ketant who was arrested on June 17, 2003 in Haiti, extradited to Miami and sentenced to 27 years in a U.S. federal prison on February 25, 2004.  In his testimony, he stated that Aristide was a “drug lord who controlled 85% the international drug traffic to Haiti”.  He told DEA agents that he paid Aristide directly $500,000 a month to have air traffic control clear in his plane used for drug transshipments.  He also made a $500,000 a year contribution to Lavalas.  Aristide, who previously declared Mr. Ketant “untouchable”, captured him and delivered him to U.S. authorities.  One diplomat noted that shortly thereafter, Aristide’s loans from the Inter American Development Bank were reinstated.

Aristide’s right hand man, the former Lavalas president of the Haitian Senate – and uncle of Preval’s favored Presidential candidate in 2010, Jean-Marie Fourel Celestin, was wanted by the Haitian police and the DEA on drug trafficking charges and went into hiding.  The U.S. Embassy released the details, and he was forced to turn himself in.  He was also extradited to the U.S. and served a reduced prison sentence in exchange for the information he shared with DEA agents.

    Aristide with drug kingpin Fourrel Celestin

Oriel Jean, Chief of Security for Aristide while he was president was arrested on suspicion of drug trafficking at Pearson airport in Toronto on March 12, 2004 debarking from a flight from the Dominican Republic.  He waived his extradition proceedings and was sent to Miami.  On March 19, 2004, he faced charges of conspiring to smuggle cocaine into the U.S.  He pled guilty to money laundering and was sentenced on August 11, 2005 to a three-year prison term on November 18, 2005.

Yvon Feuille, a close ally of Aristide and President of the Senate during the time of Aristide’s departure in 2004, was arrested on May 19, 2004 during an anti-drug operation in the Dominican Republic and placed under police surveillance in the coastal town of Les Cayes, south west of Port-au-Prince as part of a drug investigation case.

The former head of the Anti-Corruption Office (BLTS) under Aristide, Evens Brilliant, was deported on May 26, 2004 in Miami after being detained by the Multinational Interim Task Force for alleged involvement in cocaine trafficking to Colombia from Haiti via the United States.  He was indicted on June 18, 2004, but was later acquitted on October 8, 2005.

Several members of the Haitian National Police were also implicated in drug smuggling cases.  In fact, a former head of the Haitian police in exile in the U.S. testified that people he had arrested on drug charges in Haiti were actually being promoted within the Haitian police.  During his term in office, Aristide politicized the police and put members of Lavalas in key positions to protect drug trafficking and either carry out political violence and kidnappings against its opponents – or look the other way. 

Jean-Antony Nazaire was responsible for managing the President’s automobile fleet, which was used to move drugs throughout the country.  His US visa was revoked in January 2002 for his alleged involvement in drug trafficking and alleged human rights violations.  He was arrested on March 12, 2004 in Port-au-Prince. 

The former commander of the Haitian National Police Brigade, Rudy Therassan, was incarcerated on May 14, 2004 in Miami for cocaine trafficking and money laundering.  He pled guilty on April 20, 2005, and was sentenced to a 15-year term on July 13, 2005.

Former Director General of the Haitian police and member of the Aristide security team, Jean Nesly Lucien, was arrested on May 26, 2004 in Miami.  He was indicted for drug trafficking and pled guilty to money laundering on April 12, 2005.  He received a five-year sentence on July 13, 2005 after agreeing to cooperate with the US authorities’ investigation on other cases.

These cases scratch the surface of the extent of the Lavalas drug trafficking cases, but they illustrate their high level of involvement in trafficking.  There were not a few isolated cases; rather, this was an institutionalized campaign.  For further information on the drug trafficking-Lavalas link, see:

  1.     http://www.haitipolicy.org/content/1732.htm
  2.   http://www.haitipolicy.org/content/2986.htm
  3.    http://www.haitipolicy.org/content/2089.htm

Kidnapping & Political Violence
More than 99% of the kidnapping cases under his reign through today involve Lavalas members.  Prominent members linked to kidnapping include: Samba Boukman, Amaral Duclona, General Bibi, Mercius Fenel (alias Ti Wilson), Riccardo Pyram (alias Kiki), Wilkens Pierre (alias Chien Chaud) Herold Gerard, Jean Daniel Francois (alias Bibi), Dread E.T., Spander Joseph (alias Bouboule).  All of these men are Aristide’s operatives and members of Fanmi Lavalas.  One of the most well known, Amaral Duclona, was arrested in the Dominican Republic a few years ago by French authorities for killing two French diplomats.  He was the head of Operation Pakatan’n, a violent campaign to return Aristide to Haiti, and murdered dozens of Haitians opposed to Aristide.

From 1991, when Aristide took power, through 2004 when Aristide resigned, kidnapping was a small part of the Lavalas operation.  Kidnapping victims were primarily political opponents, including opposition political party members, journalists and representatives of civil society who were critical of Aristide’s regime.  After 2004, kidnapping sharply increased and became a favorite tool to intimidate opponents and deteriorate the security situation in Haiti in order to force Aristide’s return.  Members of Lavalas broadened the kidnapping targets to include children, students, businessmen, Diaspora, teachers, and other innocent victims chosen solely for the purpose of terrorizing the public in a campaign of retribution for demanding Aristide leave in 2004.  Many victims were murdered even after ransoms were paid.

We saw the same dynamic with political violence.  The Aristide machine used violent tactics to kill their opponents pre-2004; people were “necklaced” with burning tires, killed with machine guns and hacked to death with machetes.  The violence was targeted.  After the 2004 ouster, the violence broadened and a wide scale intimidation campaign, known as Operation Baghdad I and II, was launched.  More than 2,000 people were killed, including 109 police offers.  Women were raped, priests were beaten and journalists attacked.  The Operation got its name because the Aristide operatives beheaded their victims imitating Iraqi tactics.  Obviously they have not considered how things turned out for the Iraqis. 

Political observers have noted a direct correlation between increased Lavalas political activity and increased violence.  Lavalas funds much of its political activity through money raised from kidnapping and drug trafficking; therefore, when there is an uptick in Lavalas demonstrations or political campaigns, there is a corresponding uptick in violence.  For further information on this link and on political kidnappings and violence, see:

  1.    http://www.rnddh.org/article.php3?id_article=300
  2.     http://www.rnddh.org/article.php3?id_article=314
  3.     http://radiokiskeya.com/spip.php?article5520
  4.     http://metropolehaiti.com/metropole/archive.php?action=full&keyword=jacques+mathelier&sid=0&critere=0&id=8616&p=1

Corruption
After Aristide’s 2004 resignation, the Haitian General Accounting Office issued a report finding that he had embezzled almost $350 million during his nine years in office, see: http://www.haitipolicy.org/content/3284.htm  They even found more than $300,000 in cash rotting under the front porch of his home.  Where did he get that kind of money?  How do his champions explain that away?  He was framed?


Aristide made a lot of money trafficking drugs, but he and his network in the Groupe de Bourdon, a powerful business cartel that also supports current President Preval, also conspired to pilfer and raid state corporations.  This cartel with the support of Aristide and now Preval control 95% of Haiti’s economic activities, including banking, oil importation, telecommunications, customs, food, and insurance. They control the ministries of finances and commerce, the central bank, the tax office, customs and even part of the Haiti Interim Reconstruction Commission with their profiteering partners in the international community.



Specifically, Aristide sold profitable state owned companies for pennies on the dollar to foreign and domestic buyers.  For example, the state cement factory was valued at about $500 million, but was sold for only $50 million.  Aristide and his Lavalas cronies received huge cash kickbacks from the buyers for the “special pricing”.  This happened with several other state businesses that actually generated much needed revenue for Haiti.  These companies were built with an investment by the Haitian taxpayers, but taxpayers were robbed of the revenue from the undervalued sale of the company and, more importantly, were robbed of the ongoing revenue of the companies, which was previously invested in education, road and healthcare.  Instead of creating viable institutions by partly privatizing these institutions, Lavalas operatives were made rich, and they were able to secure new international allies through these sweetheart deals.  This is hardly “championing the poor” of Haiti.

Teleco is another infamous example of raiding state companies.  Teleco was the state telecom company controlling all phone traffic to and from Haiti, one of the most lucrative phone connections in the Caribbean.  When Aristide was in Washington, DC from 1992 through 1994 during his first ouster, he raided the Teleco bank accounts in the U.S. to the tune of $80 million for “living expenses”.  President George H.W. Bush allowed Aristide access to these funds as the head of the Haitian state.

When President Clinton restored Aristide to power in 1994, Aristide broke up Teleco into five companies: Fusion, Uniplex Telecom Technologies, Mount Salem Communications Group, Global, Terra Communication Group/Wecom, and Digitec.  Lavalas operatives were all given a stake in the companies.  He then awarded deals to wireless companies, like COMCEL, Digicel and Voila, through no bid contracts, which included substantive kickbacks for he and his friends.  The head of Digicel lamented in a public interview how much money he was making in poor countries like Haiti, and how he was struggling to reconcile that moral dilemma.  He touched on some weak efforts to rebuild the markets in Haiti to “give back” to the community.  These contracts were lucrative for everyone but the Haitian people.  In 2009, using the governor of the central bank, Preval finished the job of raiding Teleco by selling it to friends for a fraction of its value in a no bid contract.  For more on the raiding of state companies, see:

  1.    http://thekomisarscoop.com/tag/haiti/
  2.     http://www.haitipolicy.org/content/3297.htm
  3.   http://solutionshaiti.blogspot.com/2008/08/aristides-american-profiteers-by-mary.html

Aristide’s International Network
It was widely known in the U.S. and internationally that Aristide was directly involved in drug trafficking and human rights abuses, but unlike his colleague Panamanian President Manuel Noriega, Aristide was never tried on any charges.  Likewise, there has been no effort to pursue the money he stole from the Haitian state.  Many analysts speculate that this may be because of the international ramifications of such a trial, particularly in the United States, and who might be exposed as co-conspirators.  In fact, after the return of former dictator Jean Claude “Baby Doc” Duvalier, the UN announced that they would help the Haitian judicial system try Duvalier for his crimes carefully omitting any reference to Aristide even though he had been agitating about returning to Haiti.  The Haitian people overwhelming called for a framework to try former strongmen and secure rule of law in the country rather than focusing on one case.  Only after outrage in the Haitian community and in the Diaspora did the UN announce they would also work to try Aristide if he returned, see: http://solutionshaiti.blogspot.com/2011/02/united-nations-partisanship-in-haiti-by.html .  Again, in a country that consistently ranks as one of the most corrupt in the world, what is needed is an overall framework to try corrupt leaders.

So why has Aristide been left alone?  He has been especially adept at putting together a coalition of international support that faithfully comes to his defense.  The network of Aristide supporters is two-pronged.  One the one hand, there are the ideologists who are motivated by a righteous and distorted view of Aristide as a crusader against racial oppression and U.S. imperialism.  On the other hand, there are the foreign profiteers motivated by preferential access to business deals or lucrative monthly lobbying retainers.  Like a chameleon, Aristide blends into each group.

These two groups come together to argue that: 1. Aristide is a humble priest who threatened “business as usual” in Haiti by “championing the poor”; 2. his political party, Lavalas, is the “most popular” in Haiti and has been excluded from participating in the political process; and, 3. he was “kidnapped” by the U.S. Government in 2004 and sent into exile in South Africa against his will.  Again, the facts support none of these conclusions and few facts are used to support these allegations.

Ideologists
Most of them do not really know who Aristide is.  They were coopted and influenced by two or three corrupt ideologists that are making money with Aristide.  Aristide leverages their idealism.  This group buys into Aristide’s arguments that he has been the victim of the international community and U.S. imperialism because they align with their particular ideology.  The interesting piece here is that he cobbled together a mélange of ideologies to advance his cause: anti-imperialists, civil rights advocates, and religion, including liberation theologists, voodoo practitioners, and Catholics.  In the end, he has betrayed and undermined all these ideologies in his quest for his one true belief:  absolute power.  

There are also ideologists who well know who Aristide is and are still helping.  They believe that the U.S. is an imperialist force around the world.  Robert Maguire is considered to be the intellectual father of the campaign of political violence that erupted after Aristide’s departure.  What was supposed to be an ideological armed rebellion modeled after the FMLN in Salvador and Sandinistas in Nicaragua morphed into an organized campaign through Operation Baghdad 1 and II.  Maguire organized the Bois Caiman Conference at Trinity College modeled after the 1789 slave ceremony that led to Haiti’s revolution.  EPICA, an organization that provided political training to leftist insurgents in Latin America in the 1980s, cosponsored the event.  During the conference, according to Haitian participants, it was made clear that violent revolt was the only solution.  At the close of the conference, they drank wine symbolizing blood to seal the deal.  When the participants returned to Haiti, they were supposed to setup an ideological arm insurgency for the return of Aristide, instead they setup a petty thug crime spree.  Haitians were indignant that a foreign supporter of Aristide corrupted part of their proud history to promote thuggery.  Ironically Robert Maguire is serving at the Peace Institute in Washington. Kim Ives a longtime Aristide aide and chief propagandist is also an Aristide ideologist.

Journalists such as Max Blumental and Walt Bogdanich, along with liberal think tank leaders such as Amy Goodman at Democracy Now, have worked to undermine Haiti’s democratic opposition through a series of character assassination pieces.  For them, Aristide is a persecuted champion of the poor, and the Haitian people are wrong.  They too never address the preponderance of evidence against Aristide.

Aristide has also leveraged race to advance his cause.  He has engaged high profile race advocates such as Randall and Hazel Robinson making them millionaires with Haitian tax payer’s dollars.  Additionally, for personal gain he has also tapped into reparation advocacy efforts to get France to repay with interest the money that Haiti paid to secure its freedom from slavery. 

Aristide has also aligned with controversial figures such as Louis Farrakhan and Reverend Jeremiah Wright to advance an argument that race plays into international policy in Haiti.  But Haiti’s problems are the result of bad leadership and corruption rather than race.  Race has been experienced very differently in the U.S. and Haiti.  It is disappointing to hear those people characterize everything in terms of race.  Haiti is 99% black and proud to be the world's first black republic; however, the independence was not just about race.  Haiti's founding fathers saw beyond race to the universal values of freedom and equality. Haitians fought alongside Simon Bolivar in his quest to liberate Latin America.  They fought alongside Americans in Savannah, Georgia during the Revolutionary War to secure freedom from the British.  It was not about Latinos or Americans.  For Haitians, it was about freedom and liberation.  Haitians worry that people using race as a political tool could taint the collective memory of the Haitian independence movement.

Dr. Paul Farmer, the Deputy UN Special Envoy for Haiti and head of Partners in Health, has been vocal and high profile in his support for Aristide even signing on to the full page ad that appeared in the Miami Herald demanding Aristide’s return, see:   

  1.  http://haitisolidarity.net/downloads/Miami%20Herald%20Ad%20Jan%202011.pdf 
  2.  http://solutionshaiti.blogspot.com/2009/01/us-policy-toward-haiti-stanley-lucas.html

For many Haitians, this blatant partisanship on behalf of one of the UN’s most senior Haiti officials has been a hot button issue contributing to the overall decline in the UN’s reputation in country.  Dr. Farmer received more than $80 million in earthquake recovery money for his Partners in Health foundation and is getting most the USAID $55 million aids funds.  He has advanced Aristide’s arguments about being unfairly persecuted by the international community and certain sectors of the Haitian elite.  Such high profile support from such a well-respected UN official has lent some undeserved credibility to Aristide’s arguments

The bottom line is that Aristide has manipulated myriad ideologies to advance his cause, but has consistently proven that these ideologies are nothing more than tools in his political arsenal.  Aristide’s only real goal is securing absolute power and money.

Foreign Profiteers
On the other end, there are people in the international community that simply profit from Aristide being in power either through preferential treatment or kickbacks.

Aristide has made a number of Washington, DC lobbyists and political operatives millionaire with Haitian taxpayers money and telecommunications deals.  Some of his top lobbyists include: Ron Daniel, Ira Kurzban, Burton Wides, Brian Concannon, and others.  For their lucrative retainers, they turned a blind eye to Aristide’s well-documented corruption, human rights violations, political killings, drug trafficking, kidnappings, and election rigging.  During Aristide’s reign from 1995 to 2004, these effective and well financed lobbyists tried to mute the voice of the Haitian people and criminalize reformers and democratic activists that stood up for their rights. 

For a public account of how much money these operatives were making as Aristide lobbyists from a country where the average citizen makes $1 a day. These fees were only the tip of the iceberg.  According to one of Haiti’s former Prime Ministers, they made tens of millions more in other business deals under the table, see:

  1.    http://www.haitipolicy.org/Lobbying7.htm
  2.    http://www.haiti-info.com/?Aristide-s-American-Profiteers
  3.    http://caraibesfm.com/index.php?id=2138

Aristide’s Return
Some of these lobbyists seeking to reinstate their fat retainers and secure a piece of the lucrative reconstruction funds are trying to bring chaos again to Haiti for their boss, Jean Bertrand Aristide.  Their objective is to undermine the elections, weaken institutions and create chaos in order to create conditions for Aristide’s return to power.  In this chaos – the reasoning goes – there will be no one to arrest Aristide upon his return or organize an investigation.  The second goal is to get rid of all the paperwork within Haiti’s central bank and Ministry of Finances that will implicate them when a new President takes over.  They have lobbied the Congressional Black Caucus on Aristide direction making the argument that the CBC owes him for things that he did for them.  Some Lavalas members have confirmed that the CBC will pressure Secretary Hilary Clinton and her chief of Staff Cheryl Mills to get Aristide back to Port-au-Prince before the election.  At the UN, they are counting on Aristide’s informal advisor Paul Farmer, who is Bill Clinton’s deputy UN Special Envoy to Haiti, to remove any roadblocks that organization might raise.


While Aristide is putting pressure on the Clintons, members of his network are making arrangements for him to fly to Haiti this week.  In Aristide’s mind the elections must be aborted and retribution must be sought.  Aristide tried the retribution policy through Operation Baghdad I and II, which were two bloody campaigns of political violence against his opponents resulting in the murder of more than 2,000 people, but failed.

On a parallel and separate track from his lobbying efforts (i.e. his lobbyists would be unaware of this initiative), Aristide has instructed Lavalas thugs to prepare a hit list with names of Haitian political leaders, union representatives and civil society activists.  Names on that list include:

Historians Michel Hector and M. Michel Soukar
Union leaders Jean Lavaud Frédéric  Jean-Claude Lebrun, André Lafontant Joseph, Charles Faustin, Fritz Charles, and Patrick Numa
Professor Anthony Barbier
President of the Haitian Chamber of Commerce (CCIH), Dr. Reginald Boulos
Human rights activists Jean-Claude Bajeux
Writer M. Jean-Claude Fignolé
Coordinator of Collectif de Cité Soleil, Charles Dunais
Secretary General of Nouvelle Haïti Foundation (FNH), Mrs Yanick Lahens
Director General of Radio Vision 2000, Léopold Berlanger
Engineer Pascale Oriol
Businessman M. André Apaid
Filmaker M. Raoul Peck
M. Gesner Armand
Sociologist and researcher M. Laënnec Hurbon
M. Claude Pierre
M. Luc Smarth
Mme Geneviève L. Esper
Representative of Village de Dieu
Mrs Florence Maître
Civil engineer Pierrot Exama
Peterson C. Orélus, the head of Civil Society Initiative (ISC)
Rony Desroches, the representative of the National Association of Haitian Doctors (AMH)
Georges Beauvoir, Engineer
Women activists Jessie Benoît and Mrs Evelyne Trouillot
Writer and poet M. Gary Victor
Charles Faustin
Professor Michel Hector
Writer and poet M. Lionel Trouillot
Professor Pierre Buteau
M. Pascale Oriol
Mrs. Paulette Poujol-Oriol
Mrs Florence Maître
Writer and poet M. Franck Etienne
Peterson C. Orélus, M. Michel Acacia, Charles Baker

Aristide has the right to go home.  No Haitians should be living in exile, but hundreds are right now as a result of his brutality.  Given his vast political and economic crimes, his return should be managed by a newly elected government in the interest of stability and democracy in a country that is facing tremendous challenges.  Like Jean Claude Duvalier, Aristide will need to face justice for his political assassinations, see: http://www.haitipolicy.org/archives/Archives/Dec2000-Feb01/chery5.htm
 and the $350 million he stole during nine years from Haitian coffers, according to Haiti’s General Accounting Office, for more see: http://www.haitipolicy.org/content/3284.htm .  In the name of democracy and stability, and in the interest of the Haitian people who have yet to begin to dig out from the earthquake a year later, these lobbyists should put aside their personal ambitions and ideological zealotry and let our country breath.